Business RadioX ®

  • Home
  • Business RadioX ® Communities
    • Southeast
      • Alabama
        • Birmingham
      • Florida
        • Orlando
        • Pensacola
        • South Florida
        • Tampa
        • Tallahassee
      • Georgia
        • Atlanta
        • Cherokee
        • Forsyth
        • Greater Perimeter
        • Gwinnett
        • North Fulton
        • North Georgia
        • Northeast Georgia
        • Rome
        • Savannah
      • Louisiana
        • New Orleans
      • North Carolina
        • Charlotte
        • Raleigh
      • Tennessee
        • Chattanooga
        • Nashville
      • Virginia
        • Richmond
    • South Central
      • Arkansas
        • Northwest Arkansas
    • Midwest
      • Illinois
        • Chicago
      • Michigan
        • Detroit
      • Minnesota
        • Minneapolis St. Paul
      • Missouri
        • St. Louis
      • Ohio
        • Cleveland
        • Columbus
        • Dayton
    • Southwest
      • Arizona
        • Phoenix
        • Tucson
        • Valley
      • Texas
        • Austin
        • Dallas
        • Houston
    • West
      • California
        • Bay Area
        • LA
        • Pasadena
      • Colorado
        • Denver
      • Hawaii
        • Oahu
  • FAQs
  • About Us
    • Our Mission
    • Our Audience
    • Why It Works
    • What People Are Saying
    • BRX in the News
  • Resources
    • BRX Pro Tips
    • B2B Marketing: The 4Rs
    • High Velocity Selling Habits
    • Why Most B2B Media Strategies Fail
    • 9 Reasons To Sponsor A Business RadioX ® Show
  • Partner With Us
  • Veteran Business RadioX ®

SIMON SAYS, LET’S TALK BUSINESS: Kelli Clay of Kelli Clay, Inc., Will Nobles of Vector Choice Technology Solutions, and Javier McIntosh of McIntosh Bros Productions

December 19, 2019 by Mike

Gwinnett Studio
Gwinnett Studio
SIMON SAYS, LET'S TALK BUSINESS: Kelli Clay of Kelli Clay, Inc., Will Nobles of Vector Choice Technology Solutions, and Javier McIntosh of McIntosh Bros Productions
Loading
00:00 /
RSS Feed
Share
Link
Embed

Download file

Will Nobles, Kelli Clay, javier McIntosh, Al Simon

Kelli Clay of Kelli Clay, Inc. 

Kelli Clay, Inc. helps businesses and individuals increase productivity to achieve goals, become engaging presenters, and improve employee retention. Kelli’s signature program “Train Your Brain to Stress Less and Thrive” teaches people mind management to overcome the stress that stops them from achieving success. Examples are having doubt about reaching goals, the fear of cold calling, anxiety when public speaking, being overwhelmed from to-do lists, and dissatisfaction at work.

Will Nobles/Vector Choice Technology Solutions

Vector Choice Technology Solutions was created in 2008 and has been providing technology services to companies all over the world. Will Nobles started Vector Choice Technology Solutions with the vision of empowering clients by tailoring technology solutions to each unique need. He has spent the last few years focusing on Cyber Security and digging deep into the Dark Web to keep his clients out of it.

Javier McIntosh/McIntosh Bros Productions

McIntosh Bros Productions is an award-winning full service video production company based in Atlanta, GA that specialize in commercial, brand and event capture. Their work has been featured in 20th Century Fox Hollywood, Cannes Film Festival, and on USA Today.

Tagged With: cyber scurity, dark web, employee retention, it security, kelli clay, kelli clay inc, mcintosh bros, mcintosh bros productions, public speaking, Radiox, sales coach, sales podcast, sales techniques, sales tips, sales trainer, Sandler Training, Sandler Training by Simon, Simon Says Lets Talk Business, simon says podcast, simon says radio, stress less, vector choice, Vector Choice Technology Solutions, video production, Will Nobles

Decision Vision Episode 40: Should I Align My Business with a Cause? – An Interview with Mollye Rhea, For Momentum

November 15, 2019 by John Ray

Decision Vision
Decision Vision
Decision Vision Episode 40: Should I Align My Business with a Cause? - An Interview with Mollye Rhea, For Momentum
Loading
00:00 /
RSS Feed
Share
Link
Embed

Download file

Mike Blake and Mollye Rhea

Decision Vision Episode 40: Should I Align My Business with a Cause? – An Interview with Mollye Rhea, For Momentum

Does cause marketing really help my business? What factors should I consider in selecting a cause to align with? Answers to these questions and much more come from Mollye Rhea, For Momentum, on this edition of “Decision Vision.” Mike Blake is the host of “Decision Vision,” presented by Brady Ware & Company.

Mollye Rhea, For Momentum

For Momentum unites companies and brands with nonprofits in a way that benefits both organizations. Benefits include enhanced visibility, high-touch relationships with employees, customers and donors and significant social impact. Within the industry, this is referred to broadly as corporate social responsibility (CSR) or more concisely as cause marketing. At For Momentum®, they call these carefully designed partnerships strategic cause alliances.

Mollye Rhea

Founded in 2003 by corporate marketing and nonprofit executive Mollye Rhea, For Momentum has emerged as a leading cause marketing agency that helps companies and nonprofits prosper through partnership. Corporate Responsibility Magazine has recognized For Momentum as one of the top five cause marketing firms in the United States. Their work has been featured in the books Cause Marketing for Dummies and Corporate Social Responsibility: Doing the Most Good for Your Company and Your Cause as well as in numerous other industry publications.

While many factors set For Momentum apart from other cause marketing firms, these are the top five unique selling points (USPs) mentioned most often by their clients and industry experts. For Momentum is 100 percent focused on strategic cause alliances versus offering cause marketing as one service among many public relations, marketing and advertising options.

For Momentum’s accomplished cause marketing consultants possess a deep understanding of national/local dynamics—both corporate HQ/franchise and national nonprofit/chapter affiliate relationships.

For Momentum maintains a hiring criterion that each staff member has experience in both nonprofit and corporate environments, which equips them to provide valuable “translator” skills. Experience on both sides of the table allows them to link shared values and mutual challenges cohesively and meaningfully, leading to strategic, integrated cause marketing programs that achieve nonprofit mission objectives while delivering marketing, sales and PR benefits to the corporation.

No other cause marketing agency offers For Momentum’s proven system of identifying partnership prospects, conducting partner outreach and negotiating corporate partnerships. They customize each strategy and cultivate each pipeline for the specific client or project. With For Momentum, you won’t find cookie cutter plans, stale templates or impersonal outreach using the same tired list of prospects.

For Momentum provides a fresh, outsider perspective to help clients realize strategic priorities and adds a depth of experience and actionable plans that enable agencies, companies and nonprofits to meet their goals more quickly and efficiently.

For more information and to access resources mentioned in the show, go to the For Momentum website.

Michael Blake, Brady Ware & Company

Mike Blake, Host of “Decision Vision”

Michael Blake is Host of the “Decision Vision” podcast series and a Director of Brady Ware & Company. Mike specializes in the valuation of intellectual property-driven firms, such as software firms, aerospace firms and professional services firms, most frequently in the capacity as a transaction advisor, helping clients obtain great outcomes from complex transaction opportunities. He is also a specialist in the appraisal of intellectual properties as stand-alone assets, such as software, trade secrets, and patents.

Mike has been a full-time business appraiser for 13 years with public accounting firms, boutique business appraisal firms, and an owner of his own firm. Prior to that, he spent 8 years in venture capital and investment banking, including transactions in the U.S., Israel, Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus.

Brady Ware & Company

Brady Ware & Company is a regional full-service accounting and advisory firm which helps businesses and entrepreneurs make visions a reality. Brady Ware services clients nationally from its offices in Alpharetta, GA; Columbus and Dayton, OH; and Richmond, IN. The firm is growth minded, committed to the regions in which they operate, and most importantly, they make significant investments in their people and service offerings to meet the changing financial needs of those they are privileged to serve. The firm is dedicated to providing results that make a difference for its clients.

Decision Vision Podcast Series

“Decision Vision” is a podcast covering topics and issues facing small business owners and connecting them with solutions from leading experts. This series is presented by Brady Ware & Company. If you are a decision maker for a small business, we’d love to hear from you. Contact us at decisionvision@bradyware.com and make sure to listen to every Thursday to the “Decision Vision” podcast. Past episodes of “Decision Vision” can be found here. “Decision Vision” is produced and broadcast by the North Fulton studio of Business RadioX®.

Visit Brady Ware & Company on social media:

LinkedIn:  https://www.linkedin.com/company/brady-ware/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bradywareCPAs/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/BradyWare

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bradywarecompany/

Show Transcript

Intro: [00:00:02] Welcome to Decision Vision, a podcast series focusing on critical business decisions brought to you by Brady Ware & Company. Brady Ware is a regional full-service accounting and advisory firm that helps businesses and entrepreneurs make visions a reality.

Michael Blake: [00:00:20] And welcome to the Decision Vision, a podcast giving you, the listener, clear vision to make great decisions. In each episode, we discuss the process of decision making on a different topic, rather than making recommendations because everyone’s circumstances are different. We talk to subject matter experts about how they would recommend thinking about that decision. My name is Mike Blake and I’m your host for today’s program.

Michael Blake: [00:00:41] I’m a Director at Brady Ware & Company, a full-service accounting firm based in Dayton, Ohio, with offices in Dayton; Columbus, Ohio; Richmond, Indiana; and Alpharetta, Georgia, which is where we are recording today. Brady Ware is sponsoring this podcast. If you like this podcast, please subscribe on your favorite podcast aggregator and please also consider leaving a review of the podcast as well.

Michael Blake: [00:01:02] So, our topic today is should my business align with a cause? And I was brought to thinking about this topic because it was in the late last year, early this year, I think it was late last year, you know, I observed Nike pretty much going all in with the Colin Kaepernick scenario with the NFL. And I’m not going to comment specifically on that matter, but I did make an observation on social media that, it struck me that if I were a shareholder of Nike, I would at least like to know in advance if a company in which I was invested was going to take a polarizing or potentially polarizing position like that.

Michael Blake: [00:01:52] And I think I was kind of motivated in that viewpoint by the fact that there was a pretty demonstrative response by what turned out to be a very small minority of customers. I know that the massive response is everything from burning shoes to tearing up sweatshirts and wherever it is else that Nike sells. And, you know, quite frankly, most people who looked at that on social media said, “Blake, you’re dead wrong.” And I said, “We’ll see.”.

Michael Blake: [00:02:28] And you know, to a couple of my friends’ credit, they actually went out and bought Nike stock. So I got to give them credit, they put their money where their mouth was. And, well, you can see the history for yourself. Nike is still around. They are doing fantastically. Their stock has never been at a higher level, I believe. I think they had one of their best years ever in terms of return on that stock.

Michael Blake: [00:02:51] And clearly, I was wrong about that. And I owned up on that on social media. Imagine that, somebody saying they were wrong on social media. But, you know, the facts are the facts. And as Bill Gates likes to say, “Success is a lousy teacher.” So I had a great teacher in failure there. But it led me to sort of think about, you know, what goes into the process of a Nike when they decide that they’re going to support, in their case, a polarizing cause?

Michael Blake: [00:03:18] Not all causes are polarizing. There are many cause we can all get behind, whether it’s the United States Olympic movement, whether it is fighting cancer, whether it is stopping human trafficking, right? Not every single cause that people believe in is a polarizing one. But nevertheless, there is also a viewpoint, and Warren Buffet, I think, would agree with us because he’s written about this, that, you know, it’s really not company’s business to engage in causes at all, that business should be in the business of generating return for its shareholders.

Michael Blake: [00:03:51] And if shareholders then want to take their returns and use that to support a cause, then they should do that. And that’s how the economics should work. And again, I’m not going to necessarily debate that directly, but I want to put that out there that that is a widely held view by a person who’s been pretty successful at this whole business thing. And so, that kind of sets the stage as a platform for today’s discussion, because my bringing this on social media showed me very clearly that there’s, you know, something more that I can understand.

Michael Blake: [00:04:22] And many of you who are in business may be thinking the same thing about, you know, is there an opportunity for me to align with a cause, an organization of some kind? Is that the right thing to do? How do I kind of figure that out? And I’m not qualified to talk about that, but I have somebody here in the studio who is very qualified to talk about that. And joining us today is Mollye Rhea, founder and president of For Momentum, a cause marketing agency here in Atlanta.

Michael Blake: [00:04:54] When Mollye founded For Momentum in 2003, she recognized that she was leading one of very few agencies that specialized in cause marketing. I think that’s still true today. Since then, as cause-related marketing and corporate social responsibility have grown to a $2.6-billion industry, For Momentum has grown into one of the leading cause marketing firms in the United States. And they’re doing fantastic.

Michael Blake: [00:05:18] Through work in nonprofit development, brand marketing, and cause marketing, Mollye has acquired a unique 360-degree perspective of what fosters success and strategic cause partnerships. In her over 25 years in the field, she has created and executed cause engagement and marketing programs, strategic fundraising campaigns and organizational development strategies with dozens of nonprofit organizations and hundreds of brands, including the American Cancer Society, Boys & Girls Clubs of America, Habitat for Humanity, International—InterContinental Hotels Group, Lane Bryant, and Novartis to name a few.

Michael Blake: [00:05:53] She is a graduate of the Leadership Atlanta Class of 2012. And by the way, that’s the second best class ever. You had to be an insider of Leadership Atlanta to get that joke, but I was class of 2014. And I did not know that about you. She sits on a bunch of nonprofit boards and holds a bachelor’s degree in economics and psychology from William & Mary. Mollye, thanks so much for coming on the program.

Mollye Rhea: [00:06:18] Well, thanks so much for having me, Michael. I’m excited to be here. And wow, what a provocative promotion you started the discussion with.

Michael Blake: [00:06:26] Well, yeah, you know, you got to do something attention-grabbing to get attention on social media, right?

Mollye Rhea: [00:06:31] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:06:32] And what’s nice about that is that I learned something and it made me think more about this topic. So, thanks for coming in to talk. I don’t think I’m the only person that’s thinking about this question, right? The fact that you have the thriving business you have, I think, is Exhibit A that this is a topic that’s of a lot of interests, but it’s not a cut and dried one. So, why don’t we dive into it? So, what I like to do with a podcast is to sort of set our vocabulary. When we talk about cause marketing, what does that mean?

Mollye Rhea: [00:07:05] Well, I’m really glad you started with that, because so many people, in my experience, come to that term with a different point of view. And so, I think it’s really important to lay that groundwork right from the get go. So, I’ve been doing this type of work for a very, very long time. And back in the olden days, it was called corporate relations or something like that. And it’s really the practice by which a company is supporting a nonprofit as a part of their business practices.

Mollye Rhea: [00:07:35] And I really encourage the listeners today to take a more open-minded viewpoint to realize that that can bring many different—that can come to life in many different ways. So, some of the terminology that you hear, you know, bandied about, you know, corporate relations, community relations, cause marketing, strategic philanthropy. But these days, a really popular term, which kind of plays off of the story you told is social impact marketing. And so, companies today are looking to really engage in generating impact into our society as a side part of their business, but as a primary part of their business as well.

Mollye Rhea: [00:08:18] So, some people think of cause marketing as, you know, I’m going to buy this bottle of water and 10 cents is going to go to a charity. That is one type of cause marketing. It’s a very specific type called commercial co-venture. And we can talk about that more later. But also, different types of cause marketing, I would argue, would be, you know, the Nike program that you talked about. Other campaigns, even in employee engagement these days, in terms of really getting your employees involved in making a difference on a social issue. So, it’s a very broad landscape that we’re talking about.

Michael Blake: [00:08:54] So a question comes up, and I apologize, I’m going off the script right away, but I think it’s—I just got to get your answer on this, because I think it’s so interesting. You know, in recent months, we’ve seen a number of companies pull back in terms of their willingness to sell firearms and firearm ammunition supplies, and so forth. Is that a kind of cause marketing in your mind?

Mollye Rhea: [00:09:21] In my mind, yes.

Michael Blake: [00:09:22] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:09:22] I mean, I put those into the same landscape.

Michael Blake: [00:09:27] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:09:27] Right? So, again, cause marketing itself might be one term within this landscape, but it’s the most commonly used term.

Michael Blake: [00:09:35] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:09:35] So, I think, in fact, I was going to bring up that example based on what you said, you know, about the Colin Kaepernick Nike campaign. You know, there are a variety of societal issues where companies are starting to make a difference through their business decisions, whether to sell something. There’s a local firm called Kabbage that makes business loans and they will no longer loan to anybody who’s in ammunitions-

Michael Blake: [00:10:01] Oh, really? Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:10:03] … type of business.

Michael Blake: [00:10:03] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:10:04] So, there’s things like that. So, I think those sorts of deep integrated business decisions are more of the recent trend we’re seeing in this landscape, but you do have to be very careful. And I want to say that I think that we can continue to use this Nike example as a grounding case study, if you will. They did lose a segment of their customers. You know, their overall numbers went up, but there was a segment, just like there was a strong segment who spoke out against it and burned-

Michael Blake: [00:10:34] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:10:35] … things. And then, there was, you know, on the other end, strong, you know, affiliation with it. You have to really understand your customer base and not make those decisions based on your personal opinions, but really take into account the community that you serve if you want to make sure that you aren’t having that, you know, the tail wag the dog, so to speak, you know.

Michael Blake: [00:10:57] Yeah. And that’s a great point that I think we’re going to get back to. But it does it does bear emphasizing that, you know, cause marketing for its own sake may or may not be a great thing, but it sounds like an integral part of that notion is make sure you understand who your target market is, right?

Mollye Rhea: [00:11:15] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:11:16] And it may not be necessarily the target market that I, as a CEO or board or a decision maker, chief marketing officer, thinks as the right cause, right?

Mollye Rhea: [00:11:25] Mm hmm. That’s right.

Michael Blake: [00:11:26] So, again, using the Nike sort of the platform for this discussion, there was some risk there, I think. That turned out well for Nike, great for them, right? But, you know, because of that risk, why should a company consider taking that risk in embarking on a cause marketing campaign?

Mollye Rhea: [00:11:47] Yeah. And you know what? I think I want to interject here a different example, because I don’t want the listener to think of that as the guiding light of an example-

Michael Blake: [00:11:57] Yeah, please.

Mollye Rhea: [00:11:57] … because it’s an extreme example.

Michael Blake: [00:11:59] Yeah, please.

Mollye Rhea: [00:12:00] So, you know, there are many, many ways that companies can support nonprofit’s, you know, strict sponsorship of events or activities, things like that. They can get behind a campaign that is going to raise funds or awareness for an issue that isn’t controversial. And it doesn’t change their business model, but it’s more of a programmatic way that they can support. So, let’s talk about some of those more standardized types of campaigns, because I don’t want the listener to be frightened that, oh, it’s got to be this big extreme-

Michael Blake: [00:12:33] Yeah, good.

Mollye Rhea: [00:12:33] … you know, thing. So, let’s talk about the business benefits of a company supporting a social impact or a nonprofit mission. You know, either space. Often, they’re very interlinked. There are clear and documented benefits to a company for this type of marketing behavior. And they are things like increased sales, heightened PR, heightened awareness of the company and positive awareness of a company. So, there are a lot of great business benefits. But what I also want listeners to know is that, you know, in the trends in this space, an increasingly important target audience is your employee base. Because today our unemployment rates are very, very low.

Mollye Rhea: [00:13:21] The cost of finding a good candidate and retaining a good employee are real cost that we have to be very careful about. And there’s a mounting amount of evidence that cause marketing or a company’s support of the local community is a positive differentiator for job selection. And that when employees join a company that they feel is doing good things in the community, they’re more likely to be engaged and they’re more likely to stay employed with that company. So, why should a company consider cause marketing? Lots of different reasons. It could be PR, it could be HR.

Michael Blake: [00:13:58] You know, and I want to underscore that point as well. You know, marketing, when many of us think of marketing, frankly, myself included, we think about an outward message, right? How do we get more customers? How do we get the customers we have to love us more, buy more from us, and so forth. But you’re right, there is a marketing element internally, right, to make your employees and your associates feel great about where they are. Because at the end of the day, raising salaries can only take you so far.

Mollye Rhea: [00:14:30] That’s right. Yeah. You know, part of the overall compensation package is psychic income, right? And so, you want to feel good about the work you’re doing and you want to feel good about the company that you’re working for. And this is becoming—you know, we hear a lot about millennials, you know, we’re starting to hear now more statistics from the Gen Z population.

Michael Blake: [00:14:51] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:14:53] But these younger cohorts are absolutely motivated by community impact. And so, you know, it’s becoming more and more important as companies want to attract those younger talent.

Michael Blake: [00:15:07] And that’s been something of an adaptation for Gen X’ers like myself, right? The Gen X’ers are the, I think, last of the kind of the old school workforce where just put your head down, getting your hours, do your thing, and, you know, get in and get out. And that’s an adaptation outlook that my generation has had to change, right? Because if we try to treat our workforce in a Gen X way, we’re not going to have a workforce very long or at least not one with which we’re very happy.

Mollye Rhea: [00:15:44] Mm hmm. I think that’s right.

Michael Blake: [00:15:45] So, it sounds like you’ve segued again very nicely into the next question, which is it sounds like there’s evidence that cause marketing does have a positive impact on company performance.

Mollye Rhea: [00:15:55] Absolutely. You know, there are an increasing number of studies out there. The most common are from an agency called Cone, C-O-N-E. And if readers are interested, you can certainly Google that and you will find all sorts of different studies on this topic. But I like to cite more resources than just the primary one, because I think sometimes we can get into a rut or a routine and I think their work is fantastic. I’m not dissing that at all.

Michael Blake: [00:16:23] Right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:16:24] I follow that. But, you know, we’ve been able to find many, many other sources of information that point to the validity of this notion. I also want to point out that there are increasing numbers of corporate associations focused on this topic. One of those is the Committee to Encourage Corporate Philanthropy, CECP. And they are a group of CEOs of large organizations that very much track the benefits of this type of investment, because this is not just a, you know, flash in the pan idea.

Mollye Rhea: [00:16:59] This is something they realized they have to pay a lot of attention to. And according to CECP, 87 percent of companies are now measuring and tracking societal outcomes and using that data to inform their program development. And 80 percent of those same corporate leaders think that, they believe, it is enhancing customer loyalty and 89 percent of them feel that it’s enhancing collective purpose amongst their employees.

Mollye Rhea: [00:17:27] So, those are just some of the types of statistics. I could go on and on. I don’t want to do that because probably, a lot of your listeners are driving. And I don’t want them to fall asleep. But, you know, on our website, at For Momentum, we have a variety of resources. We compile this type of research all the time because we’re in it, you know, 365. So, free downloadable tidbits are there if your listeners want to go and download those.

Michael Blake: [00:17:53] Well, yeah, perfect. It’s all about data nowadays. So, let’s shift gears in a little bit. So, let’s say that one of those driving listeners now is saying, “You know what, this cause marketing thing is something I ought to pay more attention to.” I think the next obvious question to my mind is, is my company a good fit for it, right? Is there a profile of a company that has a good or a best fit for cause marketing as opposed to maybe a company that isn’t as good with that?

Mollye Rhea: [00:18:22] Yes and no. I mean, I think that there are some companies that, you know, have an easier footprint into the community. So, like a retailer, you know, where they can really, you know, engage, “Would you like to add a dollar? Would you like to make a donation and get a bounce back coupon?” Things like that. They have a natural affinity. But what I like to say is that when you, whoever you are as a company, are looking at putting your toe in the water on this, think about what companies—or what nonprofits, rather, what social impact mission is going to advance your business and what is the right footprint for you.

Mollye Rhea: [00:18:59] So, if I am a local company based in Atlanta, Georgia and my footprint is 100 percent Atlanta, Georgia, I probably want to pick a comparative nonprofit that impacts that same geographic space. So, you know, I need to find someone who’s like-minded, like-sized, you know, and find the right match for me. So, I’m not, as my company is not going to compete with what Nike is doing.

Michael Blake: [00:19:28] Right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:19:29] Because I don’t have the same profile or footprint.

Michael Blake: [00:19:31] Right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:19:33] So, I really think it can be any type of company, but with the right connection to a cause that makes sense. And another thing I want to point out about that is that sometimes, companies fall into a natural rut, where they just want to pick something that they care about individually. So, you know, I’m going to support, you know, something that matters to me individually, but it has no tie to their brand, whatsoever.

Mollye Rhea: [00:19:58] That’s confusing to the consumer and confusing to the employees, frankly, because it needs to be a charitable choice that matches, I call it, the three-second rule. It’s like, “Oh, I understand why this restaurant is supporting hunger issues because they’re both about food”, you know, or something basic like that. But that can really enhance the validity of the campaign when there’s a natural fit between the brands.

Michael Blake: [00:20:23] It’s almost like a joke. The second you have to explain it, you’re done.

Mollye Rhea: [00:20:26] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:20:27] Right? The joke is just never going to have the impact.

Mollye Rhea: [00:20:30] That’s right.

Michael Blake: [00:20:31] So, one thing that kind of strikes me about cause marketing is that you’re trying to find a partner. You need a partner, probably, in some constraints. I guess you could have a completely unidirectional cause marketing campaign, but I don’t think that’s what you’re all about. What is the role of the partner, the nonprofit or philanthropic partner in the cause marketing relationship?

Mollye Rhea: [00:20:56] Yeah. So, actually, I want to go back and talk about what you’ve just said.

Michael Blake: [00:20:59] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:21:00] Which is that, you know, it doesn’t make sense for it to be unidirectional, but in fact, that is one of the trends we’re seeing, which I am really sad about. You know, I think there are a lot of companies that have decided to do their own—they’ve picked their own issue and they’re going to create their own solution to it. You know, and some companies can do that. I mean, they have enough wherewithal to really, you know, go in there.

Mollye Rhea: [00:21:25] I’m a big proponent that if there is a nonprofit that is working in that issue space, find a way to work with them because it does help to bring multiple voices to an issue and not later get maybe accused of self-dealing or, you know, something that’s self-serving. There are many, many benefits that the nonprofit can bring to the partnership table. And you have to have a really robust business discussion about that. So, it’s really important to find a partner who is going to match your business objectives.

Mollye Rhea: [00:22:02] So, for example, the nonprofit partner brings, first of all, an expertise into the issue space that you are wanting to address. They live in this space 24/7, so they should be bringing some special expertise. With that comes connections with stakeholders and opinion leaders in the space. They bring a level of awareness, a level of authenticity. They can bring marketing benefits. They have followers and they may have social media following or they may have, you know, donors, constituents. So, they do have their own audience that they can bring to the marketing equation.

Michael Blake: [00:22:39] You know, that unilateral element brings to mind something that just came up in the news. Apple just announced they’re going to put, I think, $2 billion into building housing in Silicon Valley because California has a massive housing problem. Basically, their own employees cannot afford to live in the state.

Mollye Rhea: [00:22:57] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:22:58] Facebook is doing something similar. And what struck me about that was, you know, I don’t know that necessarily building houses is the answer. And I hope—it wasn’t clear from what I read that they’re partnering with anybody. But, you know, perhaps, they should be. I certainly hope that they are, because Apple is not in the multi-family real estate business, as far as I’m aware, right? And simply building houses may not be the issue, right?

Michael Blake: [00:23:28] In my view, I think the issue is most likely zoning or something of that nature that prevents homes from being built where they ought to be built. And it would be interesting to see how the Apple initiative unfolds, right? Because they’re clearly targeting a cause somewhat self-serving. But that’s okay, because there is a collateral good that’s coming out of it. But it would be interesting to see if that winds up being part of a partnership or not. Right now, it’s not clear.

Mollye Rhea: [00:23:55] Yeah. And I don’t know because I haven’t studied that particular topic. But I do know of many nonprofit players that could be excellent in that space. You know, I think it’s called Community Enterprise Partners that we did some work with few years ago, whose mission is to talk about the fact with the increasing amounts of rent in key cities and how people can’t afford to live in the places where we need them to.

Mollye Rhea: [00:24:19] So, they obviously are working in this space 24/7 and at least could bring thought leadership to that process. So, that’s a great example, Michael, where I hope that whatever the issue is, I think it’s imperative that companies look to others in the space to see what they can learn before they go running down a path, you know, without all the information available.

Michael Blake: [00:24:42] So, let’s say we go through some process, we identified that nonprofit partner, you know, what are some of the typical contributions a nonprofit partner makes to that relationship?

Mollye Rhea: [00:24:53] So, again, it depends on the nature of the relationship. It can be extremely directed. It could be that the company is funding a specific project of the nonprofit and they are literally delivering, you know, the project. But many times, nonprofits can bring—you know, as I was saying earlier, people are aware of the nonprofits, so they’re bringing awareness to the topic. They are bringing constituency. They are bringing, you know, increase. I’ll give you an example. So, one of our clients is Habitat for Humanity, and they do a program called Home is the Key. And they’re a variety of corporate partners that engage in that campaign.

Mollye Rhea: [00:25:35] And in that case, what Habitat is bringing to it is, you know, obviously, the expertise on the issue. But they are also bringing celebrities to the floor, right? So, the Property Brothers are celebrity spokespeople for this event. They are investing in a big PR campaign that then the companies receive the spotlight of as a part of that initiative. So, instead of building the whole program from scratch on the corporate shoulders, the corporate can engage in a program that the nonprofit is bringing to the marketplace. And they are tremendous amounts of marketing and sales benefits, you know.

Michael Blake: [00:26:11] Okay. So, often, the nonprofit brings their own infrastructure-

Mollye Rhea: [00:26:15] Yes.

Michael Blake: [00:26:15] … basically. And the benefit there is, yeah, you could do it unilaterally, but why are we reinventing the wheel, right?

Mollye Rhea: [00:26:21] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:26:22] And especially in that case, you know, they’ve got celebrities, which, you know, most companies want to line with and so forth. And it sounds like—and I appreciate that it sort of depends. You know, it could be as simple also as simply using, you know, doing co-branding logos, trademarks, things of that nature.

Mollye Rhea: [00:26:41] Absolutely.

Michael Blake: [00:26:41] So, as I understand it, there’s really a sort of a whole spectrum of the sky’s the limit. And of course, another function of that is going to be, you know, how big the nonprofit itself is, right?

Mollye Rhea: [00:26:50] Yes.

Michael Blake: [00:26:50] The united way can do more than, say, you know, the local Chamblee chapter of St. Vincent de Paul, which is a thrift store that, you know, helps people in poverty in the Chamblee area.

Mollye Rhea: [00:27:04] Yeah, but that’s a good example of if I am a company based in Chamblee, you know-

Michael Blake: [00:27:10] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:27:10] … St. Vincent de Paul is gonna be more attractive to me-

Michael Blake: [00:27:12] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:27:13] … because there is an authentic connection between my business and that nonprofit’s mission. So, just to kind of tie that back to what I was saying earlier about, you know, finding the right partner, don’t forget those local ones-

Michael Blake: [00:27:27] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:27:27] … if you’re a local company.

Michael Blake: [00:27:27] Is it hard to mix the for profit and nonprofit cultures? Are there any issues with them sort of having being able to talk the same language? Because there are probably cases where their goals are not 100 percent aligned all the time.

Mollye Rhea: [00:27:43] Yes, absolutely. 100 percent of the time, they are not 100 percent aligned.

Michael Blake: [00:27:48] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:27:49] I can tell you that. They may come together for a common objective in, you know, a particular program or initiative. But it’s very important to take into account the respective needs of each of the partners and their business realities, their business resource mixes, their stakeholders and who they’re reporting to. I would say that you could make the same argument in any business to business relationship building. Whenever you bring two partners together, they’re going to have different goals and different missions. But I will say the nonprofit environment is more starkly different from a corporate environment, you know, just given the fact that it’s a nonprofit.

Mollye Rhea: [00:28:28] However, where you can really bridge that gap is by having very straightforward communication and collaborative planning and really authentic clear conversations. So, you know, Business A wants this set of benefits and the nonprofit needs be able to say, this is what I can do and this is what I can’t. And some of those are regulatory-related. You know, like, for example, a nonprofit can’t overly promote a corporate entity or it becomes unrelated business income tax. There are implications for EBIT. So, you know, the company needs to respect the nonprofit’s, you know, boundaries and vice versa.

Michael Blake: [00:29:08] Okay. And to that end, I believe that some companies will actually create a role inside the company for somebody to be their, in effect, cause marketing ambassador, their person that represents the company for the nonprofits with whom they cooperate. And I suspect that model can work well because then, that person is fluent in both languages, basically, if you will. Is that a necessity in your mind? Is that best practices? Can you live without it? Can you talk a little bit about, you know, how important that role is?

Mollye Rhea: [00:29:43] Yeah. So, I don’t think it needs to be someone’s full time job, but there needs to be someone who’s put in charge, if you will, of managing the relationships. And so, I guess I want to answer this in a couple of different way. So, it doesn’t have to be—you know, I don’t want to dissuade companies that can’t afford a full-time position because you can certainly do this. You can have effective partnerships without it being a full-time role.

Mollye Rhea: [00:30:08] In fact, some of the largest companies that we work with as customers only have a couple of people and they’re doing billions of dollars, sometimes, of good. So, you don’t have to have a full-time person to get engaged in cause. The other thing I want to say is that we’ve been doing a piece of research. We’ve now completed our third cycle of this research with corporate partnership decision makers. And, you know, in the trends and in the way that the landscape changes, there came a time where there was this individual who was responsible. And what we’re seeing now is that that’s not the case, that it’s actually a shared responsibility across many different departments.

Mollye Rhea: [00:30:50] And so, we asked the question in our research, who from your corporate structure is involved in the decision making? And we found marketing, PR, HR, Community Relations, C-suite and sometimes, a special committee. So, I think that the company needs to make those decisions about where the most natural fits are and don’t work in a silo. Recognize that you need to engage counterparts from all those departments that I just mentioned in your planning process or you will end up with a silo, and that’s not good.

Michael Blake: [00:31:24] Okay. So, I want to switch gears a little bit. What are some trends you’re seeing out there that are, for lack of a better term, hot in terms of cause marketing? What are some emerging things that a lot of companies are looking to do? Whether it’s practices, nature of the cause themselves. What are you seeing out there?

Mollye Rhea: [00:31:40] So, let’s go back to your first topic of the morning, which was the, you know, Colin Kaepernick, you know, taking on a social issue. That is a trend. It’s not for everyone. It’s for a select few of brands that have an avant-garde element to their brand personality. But increasingly, we are seeing some companies taking this very strong stance on a particular social impact issue. So, that is a trend. And we actually have some resources on that, if anyone’s interested. But sort of to the more broad-based approach, actually, a trend is that the United Nations came out with some sustainable development goals. And I think it was 18 different areas of impact, where, you know, United Nations members from around the globe identified 18 common areas that any country needs to be sustainable.

Mollye Rhea: [00:32:34] So, poverty, education, hunger, water, you know, et cetera, and health. And what I’m seeing is an increasing trend as that companies are identifying from these sustainable business goals, development goals from the United Nations, they’re identifying we’re going to impact, you know, area 2, 8, and 12, whatever their numbers are that they pick. And companies are starting to speak in lingo, in that lingo of, “Well, in, you know, goal 12, we’re making this, you know, headway, this much headway. So, it’s a way of really working collaboratively across different corporate segments towards mutually beneficial goals. Does that make sense?

Michael Blake: [00:33:19] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:33:19] And so, that’s a trend. And then, the other trend that I want to highlight sort of as a top three trend is the increasing incidence of digital. So, as our society becomes more and more digitally focused, we are seeing lots more partnership activations in the digital realm.

Michael Blake: [00:33:39] Okay. And actually, to that end, is there a risk to defy, embark on cause marketing? And, you know, I’m not doing it yet. Is there a risk of it being somehow disruptive to my existing conventional marketing efforts? I imagine there must be some integration issues because I think that’s the expertise that you lend. So, if that is true, can you talk about kind of what some of those challenges might be?

Mollye Rhea: [00:34:08] So, how cause could be disruptive to the rest of your business plan?

Michael Blake: [00:34:12] Yeah, or, you know, cause marketing is a different kind of marketing, just like digital marketing has become disruptive to more conventional analog methods, right? I guess I’m posing a hypothesis that cause marketing has the potential to be similarly disruptive because I think the way you have to go about, the skill sets required, the stakeholders are different, right? And so, I guess my question is, is it fair to characterize this cause marketing as somewhat disruptive? And if so, is that something that needs to be actively thought about, managed by a company that is thinking of pursuing it?

Mollye Rhea: [00:34:52] So, I guess where this takes my mindset, Michael, is to think about, you know, all good things in moderation, right? So, if you were to abandon, if a company was to abandon some of their traditional marketing methods toward strictly cause, I think they could lose themselves, frankly, in it, because they need to—it needs to be a piece of your overall communications or employment objectives, not the only thing you do.

Mollye Rhea: [00:35:22] So, that’s something that I think you have to like integrate it into a bigger plan as opposed to, like, for instance, if a company suddenly went 100 percent digital and forgot all their other kinds of marketing, those repercussions will be clear. I think anybody can understand that analogy. So, I’m saying the same thing would happen if you went too top-heavy in cause. And maybe I’m honestly just a little too close to it, but I don’t see it as a risk, in general.

Michael Blake: [00:35:53] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:35:53] Here’s another example of where it could be risky. It could’ve been risky with Nike. You know, if they don’t understand their audience or if they choose a cause activity that doesn’t resonate with their target audience. That could become disruptive because they’ve suddenly changed their brand personality, probably unintentionally.

Michael Blake: [00:36:15] Right. And another example, we’ve talked about Nike, but Gillette with their “Me too” ad about a-year-and-a-half ago, right? That had some ramifications as well. In some cases, somewhat stronger, I think.

Mollye Rhea: [00:36:26] If you’re thinking of the ad where it was like the gentleman that they were trying to encourage men to be, it wasn’t “Me too.”

Michael Blake: [00:36:37] Well, but they sort of aligned—okay, you’re the marketing expert.

Mollye Rhea: [00:36:42] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:36:42] I’m not. I’ve heard it referred to as that.

Mollye Rhea: [00:36:44] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:36:45] So if it’s not, then I stand corrected. But I’m referring to the ad where they try to redefine a sense of what it means to be a man.

Mollye Rhea: [00:36:54] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:36:55] Which is a different relationship with women, which is a different relationship with other men, which is different relationships with people who are vulnerable. And I think that—is that a fair characterization?

Mollye Rhea: [00:37:06] Well, you know, it’s interesting. I think that your perception of it is a great example of where it can get dangerous, right?

Michael Blake: [00:37:11] Okay.

Mollye Rhea: [00:37:12] Because the campaign, in its essence, was designed supposedly to educate men to make more responsible choices that consider other people’s feelings more, like, you know, the way they raise their sons or the way that they talk to women or whatever. That is a great example of a campaign that had a really positive and negative reaction in the marketplace. I think they’ve—I haven’t seen it lately, so I don’t know if they’ve withdrawn or gone back to the drawing board or exactly where they stand on that, but I don’t think they expected that big of a reaction on the negative side.

Michael Blake: [00:37:51] Right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:37:52] So, that’s a good example of really needing to understand your target audience. And if a portion of your target audience resonates with that, you know, that could be a strategic decision. It could have been a mistake. And I don’t know because I wasn’t involved. And so, I don’t know the inner workings.

Michael Blake: [00:38:09] Right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:38:10] But I’ll give you another example and I don’t feel comfortable saying who it is because it was a business-to-business conversation.

Michael Blake: [00:38:16] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:38:17] But it was a, again, company that targets men and they had decided to, in their own way, try to redefine how men relate to their emotions. This was, you know, the stance that this brand took was, “We’re going to teach men that it’s okay to be in touch with their emotions.” And they did some, you know, post-campaign research and their audience didn’t like it. Like, “Don’t tell me how I’m supposed to feel.” So, you really do need to understand your audience. And especially if you’re going for something that’s provocative or brand changing, potentially could have people have a different perception of your brand, those are good examples of where it can be very disruptive. So, what could they have done differently? They could have picked a—those are also cases where there was no cause. There was no nonprofit partner. They’re just stating like, you know-

Michael Blake: [00:39:15] I hadn’t thought about that. Yeah, that sounds exactly right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:39:18] So, if they wanted to generate something, maybe that would have been a good time to find a partner that has a mission that they could say we’re supporting their mission, not we are changing who we are.

Michael Blake: [00:39:29] Interesting. Okay. And to that point about picking partners, I would imagine not all partners are created equal, right? And even if you identify with the partner’s potential cause, they may not be the right partner for you, right?

Mollye Rhea: [00:39:46] That’s true.

Michael Blake: [00:39:48] And sometimes, there can be a size mismatch. You know, an interesting story, you know, one cause I paid some attention to is Lou Gehrig’s disease research, ALS Society—ALS Association. And, you know, as everybody knows, it had the ice bucket campaign, which I did, and boy, ice water’s cold.

Mollye Rhea: [00:40:12] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:40:13] But an interesting thing about that was that all of a sudden, the ALS Association of America came into a windfall, about $130 million. They just did not have the infrastructure-

Mollye Rhea: [00:40:23] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:40:25] … to manage that kind of cash, right? Their organization had to completely reorient to make sure that that money was used well, right, and wisely. Can that be an issue in the cause marketing space, too? Maybe there’s a size mismatch or just fundamental characteristics of certain nonprofits that may not make it a good partner, even if you agree with the cause?

Mollye Rhea: [00:40:49] Yeah. So, I just want to go back just to clarify for a moment about the wonderful, fabulous ice bucket challenge phenomenon.

Michael Blake: [00:40:56] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:40:58] That was not cause marketing.

Michael Blake: [00:40:59] I understand.

Mollye Rhea: [00:40:59] Okay, okay. I just want to make sure your listeners understand that that is an example of a movement that caught wind. And I think every nonprofit in the world dreams of having that problem-

Michael Blake: [00:41:11] True.

Mollye Rhea: [00:41:12] … of creating that magic in a bottle, you know, where they can create something. Another beautiful example of something that was a game changer was cystic fibrosis.

Michael Blake: [00:41:22] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:41:22] So, they literally invested in research and the research paid off. And so, they became a part-owner of a pharmaceutical product that serves cystic fibrosis. I might not be getting this 100 percent right.

Michael Blake: [00:41:37] I think that sounds right. I’ve read that.

Mollye Rhea: [00:41:39] And it created just a tremendous amount of income. So, I think it’s incumbent on the nonprofit board to be prepared with, “This is our plan and this is our plan if we grow this much and this is our plan if we grow that much”, you know, so that they are strategically staying aligned to their mission and bringing that to life. In terms of a cause program that just has taken off and changes the direction, I think—I can’t think of a real example.

Mollye Rhea: [00:42:07] But I can tell you that, you know, if the nonprofit or if the message of the campaign was focused on a tiny issue and then, you had too much funding and you couldn’t spend all that on the issue, I think it’s really important to make sure that the focus area is broad enough that you’re not going to get into that topic. So, it gives me the chance to say this, many times companies decide that they want to create impact on a particular subset of a bigger issue. And sometimes, it’s better just to help the broader issue and not get so singularly focused on this small little piece.

Michael Blake: [00:42:45] Sure. Yeah. Because even if, say, Coca-Cola decided there is hook of the firehose and dumped, you know, $10 million into that St. Vincent de Paul charity in Chamblee, right? They’d be overwhelmed.

Mollye Rhea: [00:42:58] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:42:58] Most likely. And it wouldn’t work very well for everybody. So-

Mollye Rhea: [00:43:02] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:43:02] … you know, pick not just the cause, there’s a bullet point I want to kind of tease out, I think we’re doing that, is that picking the partner for a match is just as important as picking the cause. Is that fair?

Mollye Rhea: [00:43:14] Picking the partner that is delivering into the mission space that you’re interested in?

Michael Blake: [00:43:21] Correct. That’s right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:43:21] Yes. Yes, I do agree with that. And an example that I wanted to share, you know, when you think about that, so let’s say that your organization, you know, one that many of us know is breast cancer, right?

Michael Blake: [00:43:33] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:43:33] So, lots of people want to support breast cancer. And, you know, you really need to do homework on your nonprofit partner because, you know, there’s one breast cancer organization that works, let’s say, on funding research. And there’s a different breast cancer organization whose mission is to serve people who currently are dealing with breast cancer and make it easier for them, make it—help them get to their doctor’s appointments or things like that. And yet, a third breast cancer organization is all about prevention messaging and warning signs and things like that. So, really look at what it is you’re trying to accomplish within the mission space and make sure that you’re finding the right partner who will help you with that particular goal.

Michael Blake: [00:44:11] All right.

Mollye Rhea: [00:44:12] Not all nonprofits focus on exactly the same things.

Michael Blake: [00:44:15] Yeah.

Mollye Rhea: [00:44:16] Even if they’re all about, say, breast cancer.

Michael Blake: [00:44:18] Yeah, that’s true. I mean, many of them are new ones and that the cause itself is so big that there are subsectors of that cause and effect.

Mollye Rhea: [00:44:26] That’s right.

Michael Blake: [00:44:27] Well, Mollye, we’re running out of time but this has been great, I’ve learned a lot. And if I’ve learned a lot, I’m confident at least some of our listeners have learned something. So, thank you for doing this. There’s a lot more we could talk about. I’ve only gotten through about half the questions I want to talk about today, but that’s a good thing. How can people contact you if they want to find out more about this and explore maybe this for their own business, their own nonprofit?

Mollye Rhea: [00:44:52] Okay, great. Well, so, you know, I have been working in this space for a very, very long time, so I’m hyper interested in it. And as a part of our return to the community, we conduct research every year into different factors of how to bring a cause partnership to life, what sorts of benefits can you seek and things like that. So, I would hope that some of your listeners might find it of interest to go to our website, to our resource page and download some of our free resources.

Mollye Rhea: [00:45:20] So, that’s For Momentum, formomentum.com/resources. If you have specific questions for us, there’s a Contact Us page. We’d love to hear from you. Be more than happy to help direct you to resources or point—answer questions, things like that. That’s just a part of our giving it back to the industry practices kind of things. But I do want to shout out to a couple of others in the cause landscape that I think produce excellent resources for the listeners. So Engage for Good is the association of people in this profession. And they do a fantastic job of constantly bringing, you know, information to light.

Mollye Rhea: [00:46:00] They have research resources, they have free webinars, they have newsletters for free that listeners can sign up for. And a third one that I would mention is a newsletter called Selfish Giving. And it’s produced by a guy out of Boston named Joe Waters, who’s a pal of mine. And he is really funny. And so, most of his, you know, articles have some entertainment flair to them as well, but really, really great examples. And he tends to focus a lot on small companies. So, you know, some of your listeners, if they’re not the Nikes of the world, but they’re a more moderate-sized company, they might find Joe’s content very realistic.

Michael Blake: [00:46:37] Very good. All right. Well, that’s going to wrap it up for today’s program. I’d like to thank Mollye Rhea so much for joining us and sharing her expertise with us. We’ll be exploring a new topic each week, so please tune in so that when you’re faced with your next business decision, you have clear vision when making it. If you enjoy these podcasts, please consider leaving a review with your favorite podcast aggregator. It helps people find us so that we can help them. Once again, this is Mike Blake. Our sponsor is Brady Ware & Company, and this has been the Decision Vision podcast.

Tagged With: CPa, CPA firm, Dayton accounting, Dayton business advisory, Dayton CPA, Dayton CPA firm, Decision Vision, Employee Engagement, employee retention, Enterprise Community Partners, Facebook, For Momentum, Gen X, Habitat for Humanity, Michael Blake, Mike Blake, millennials, Mollye Rhea, Nike, Non-Profits, social impact, St. Vincent de Paul, sustainable development, United Nations

Stacey Reece with Spherion and Matt Pruitt with The Matt Pruitt Agency

August 13, 2019 by Beau Henderson

North Georgia Business Radio
North Georgia Business Radio
Stacey Reece with Spherion and Matt Pruitt with The Matt Pruitt Agency
Loading
00:00 /
RSS Feed
Share
Link
Embed

Download file

Beau Henderson, Stacey Reece, Matt Pruitt, Dr. Bill Lampton

Stacey Reece/Spherion

Welcome to Spherion in Gainesville, Georgia! If you’re searching for a job or considering a career move, Spherion would love to help you achieve your work goals. Locally owned, the Spherion Gainesville team has connections to the area’s most respected employers and insight into up-and-coming career opportunities. Partnering together, you’ll have a team of experienced staffing professionals working on your behalf to give you a real advantage in your job pursuits.

Matt Pruitt/The Matt Pruitt Agency

The Matt Pruitt Agency serves the state of Georgia in pretty much all aspects of insurance.  Matt Pruitt helps people with their personal coverages as well as helping business owners solve issues with not only commercial insurance but health insurance as well.  After sitting down with The Matt Pruitt Agency, business owners can build more value with their employees as well as improve retention.

 

 

 

Tagged With: Dr. bill lampton, employee benefits, employee retention, Gainesville, health insurance, insurance, insurance agency, insurance coverage, Matt Pruitt, north georgia business radio, spherion, Spherion Gainesville, spherion staffing, stacey reece, staffing professionals, The Matt Pruitt Agency

Decision Vision Episode 8: Should I Hire a Recruiter? – An Interview with Joanna Cheng, Creative Financial Staffing (CFS)

March 28, 2019 by John Ray

Decision Vision
Decision Vision
Decision Vision Episode 8: Should I Hire a Recruiter? – An Interview with Joanna Cheng, Creative Financial Staffing (CFS)
Loading
00:00 /
RSS Feed
Share
Link
Embed

Download file

Joanna Cheng, Creative Financial Staffing (CFS), and Mike Blake, Host of “Decision Vision”

Should I Hire a Recruiter?

Should I hire a recruiter? What’s the best way to work with a recruiter? Michael Blake, Director of Brady Ware & Company and Host of the Decision Vision podcast, interviews Joanna Cheng on these questions and much more in this edition of Decision Vision.

Joanna Cheng, Managing Director and Branch Manager, Creative Financial Staffing (CFS)

Joanna Cheng, Creative Financial Staffing (CFS)

Joanna Cheng is a Managing Director and Branch Manager with Creative Financial Staffing (CFS). CFS is a leading, employee-owned accounting and financial staffing firm—the largest one founded by CPA firms. With more than two decades of experience helping companies locate, attract and hire exceptional accounting & finance professionals, CFS has unique resources to better understand hiring needs, attract higher-caliber candidates and assess candidate potential. Established in 1994, CFS today operates 30+ offices across 21 states and the Caribbean. Serving most major U.S. markets and beyond, CFS connects companies with candidates, from entry-level to executive level, temporary to direct hire and project support to interim management.

CFS has twice been named to Forbes’ list of “Best Professional Recruiting Firms” and twice cited by LinkedIn as one of the “Most Socially Engaged Staffing Agencies.”

Michael Blake, Brady Ware & Company

Mike Blake, Host of “Decision Vision”

Michael Blake is Host of the Decision Vision podcast series and a Director of Brady Ware & Company. Mike specializes in the valuation of intellectual property-driven firms, such as software firms, aerospace firms and professional services firms, most frequently in the capacity as a transaction advisor, helping clients obtain great outcomes from complex transaction opportunities. Mike is also a specialist in the appraisal of intellectual properties as stand-alone assets, such as software, trade secrets, and patents.

He has been a full-time business appraiser for 13 years with public accounting firms, boutique business appraisal firms, and an owner of his own firm. Prior to that, he spent 8 years in venture capital and investment banking, including transactions in the U.S., Israel, Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus.

Brady Ware & Company

Brady Ware & Company is a regional full-service accounting and advisory firm which helps businesses and entrepreneurs make visions a reality. Brady Ware services clients nationally from its offices in Alpharetta, GA; Columbus and Dayton, OH; and Richmond, IN. The firm is growth minded, committed to the regions in which they operate, and most importantly, they make significant investments in their people and service offerings to meet the changing financial needs of those they are privileged to serve. The firm is dedicated to providing results that make a difference for its clients.

Decision Vision Podcast Series

Decision Vision is a podcast covering topics and issues facing small business owners and connecting them with solutions from leading experts. This series is presented by Brady Ware & Company. If you are a decision maker for a small business, we’d love to hear from you. Contact us at decisionvision@bradyware.com and make sure to listen to every Thursday to the Decision Vision podcast. Past episodes of Decision Vision can be found here. Decision Vision is produced and broadcast by Business RadioX®.

 

Visit Brady Ware & Company on social media:

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/brady-ware/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bradywareCPAs/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/BradyWare

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bradywarecompany/

Show Transcript:

Intro: [00:00:02] Welcome to Decision Vision, a podcast series focusing on critical business decisions brought to you by Brady Ware & Company. Brady Ware is a regional, full-service accounting and advisory firm that helps businesses and entrepreneurs make vision a reality.

Michael Blake: [00:00:21] And welcome to Decision Vision, a podcast giving you, the listener, clear vision to make great decisions. In each episode, we’ll discuss the process of decision making on a different topic. Rather than making recommendations because everyone’s circumstances are different, we talk to subject matter experts about how they would recommend thinking about that decision.

Michael Blake: [00:00:39] My name is Mike Blake, and I’m your host for today’s program. I’m a Director at Brady Ware & Company, a full-service accounting firm based in Dayton, Ohio, with offices in Dayton; Columbus, Ohio; Richmond, Indiana; and Alpharetta, Georgia, which is where we are recording today. Brady Ware is sponsoring this podcast. If you like this podcast, please subscribe on your favorite podcast aggregator, and please consider leaving a review of the podcast as well.

Michael Blake: [00:01:05] So, today, our discussion is going to be about whether to work with a recruiter when hiring new employees. And talent acquisition is a funny topic because we deal with human beings. And human beings are, for the most part, the most unpredictable things on the planet. And you don’t know necessarily what you’re going to get when you’re hiring. You don’t even know what you’re going to get when you get through the interview process. I mean, you pick a resume, you don’t even know what’s going to show up and walk through that door.

Michael Blake: [00:01:38] And in an environment now, we have some 4% unemployment and talent is not exactly growing on trees. And if you live in the Atlanta area, you can see that just by the traffic that’s in the area. You know that everybody is back to work because it, now, takes about an hour to get from [Chamblee] to Alpharetta. Talent is hard to find. But the question is you can, of course, go to the route where you can try to find talent “for free,” and we’ll find out just how free free actually is, or you can pay for help.

Michael Blake: [00:02:10] And here to help us with that conversation is my good friend, my pal, Joanna Cheng, who is Managing Partner and Branch Manager of Creative Financial Staffing in Atlanta. Prior to joining CFS, she worked for an Atlanta CPA firm in the audit practice for seven years. So, she’s a recovering CPA just like I’m a recovering investment banker and venture capitalist. She holds a bachelor’s degree from Kennesaw State University and is an avid adventure racer. I hope I’m saying that right.

Michael Blake: [00:02:40] CFS is the leading employee-owned accounting and financial staffing firm, the largest one founded by CPA firms. With more than two decades of experience helping companies locate, attract, and hire exceptional accounting and finance professionals, CFS has unique resources to better understand hiring needs, attract higher caliber candidates, and assess candidate potential.

Michael Blake: [00:02:59] Established in 1994, CFS today operates over 30 offices across 21 states and the Caribbean. Serving most major US markets and beyond, CFS connects companies with candidates from entry level to executive level, temporary to direct hire, and project support to intern management. CFS has twice been named to Forbes List of Best Professional Recruiting Firms and twice cited by LinkedIn as one of the most socially-engaged staffing agencies. And with that, my pal, Joanna Cheng. Joanna, thanks for coming in.

Joanna Cheng: [00:03:31] Thanks, Mike, for having me.

Michael Blake: [00:03:35] So, I got to ask this first. You have an office in the Caribbean. I mean, that’s just a front for like resort staff, or does one of your owners live in the Caribbean, and that’s how they sort of minimize their taxes?

Joanna Cheng: [00:03:47] We have an office in Puerto Rico, and it’s actually a pretty robust practice.

Michael Blake: [00:03:51] Okay.

Joanna Cheng: [00:03:51] Even in the light of recent events.

Michael Blake: [00:03:54] In light of the fact that island destroyed a year ago.

Joanna Cheng: [00:03:56] Yeah, there were interests, yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:03:58] So, that is a robust practice. That’s interesting.

Joanna Cheng: [00:04:02] Well, I mean, I think, as of late, they’ve had some struggles. But, again, from a temporary staffing perspective, there certainly continues to be a need for people to kind of fill the gaps.

Michael Blake: [00:04:12] Yeah, okay. That’s interesting. I would not have guessed that. So, I mean, I’ve given out, sort of, your name, rank, and serial number. You’re at CFS. You’ve been there. I think you’ve been there as long as I’ve known you. I’m not sure that I knew you when you’re an accountant, maybe for six months.

Joanna Cheng: [00:04:29] I don’t know. I left public accounting at the end of 2011. Joined CFS beginning of 2013. So-

Michael Blake: [00:04:38] Okay. So, there’s a couple of year overlap actually but-

Joanna Cheng: [00:04:40] Yeah, six years now at CFS officially.

Michael Blake: [00:04:42] But they locked me down the sixth floor of the building, so they didn’t let me out much.

Joanna Cheng: [00:04:46] Exactly. We are probably like ships in the night.

Michael Blake: [00:04:49] Yes. It’s ships in the night that were locked and never allowed to see one another.

Joanna Cheng: [00:04:53] Just like when I was an audit. It’s funny because I was gone for a year from the firm, and when I came back people, I’d run into people, and they’d say, “Oh, I haven’t seen you for a while. Have you been in out in the field?” And I’m like, “Yeah. I’ve actually not worked here for a year, but I’m back.”

Michael Blake: [00:05:07] And thanks for noticing.

Joanna Cheng: [00:05:10] It’s like I just took a hiatus.

Michael Blake: [00:05:11] A walkabout.

Joanna Cheng: [00:05:13] Right. I was just very long on it.

Michael Blake: [00:05:15] A self-audit, maybe you can call it that. So, what do you do at CFS? I mean, it sounds like you’re basically the Grand Poobah, the head honcho, the big cheese. Is that fair, at least, for the Atlanta office?

Joanna Cheng: [00:05:28] Right, queen of middle management here in Atlanta.

Michael Blake: [00:05:30] Queen of middle management.

Joanna Cheng: [00:05:31] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:05:31] Okay. Your highness.

Joanna Cheng: [00:05:31] I run the Atlanta office for CFS. We’re a national firm. And so, I manage a team of recruiters. And we are able to help on a temporary or direct hire basis, kind of, at any level, as long as it relates to accounting and finance within the middle market.

Michael Blake: [00:05:49] And how many people do you have on your staff right no?

Joanna Cheng: [00:05:51] We have four. We’re a team of five.

Michael Blake: [00:05:53] Okay, team of five. So, as I said, you’re a recovering CPA as I’m a recovering investment banker, et cetera, et cetera, recovering adult. What made you make that jump? When did you wake up one day and said, “Yeah, I just can’t count stuff anymore. I’ve got to go be me.”

Joanna Cheng: [00:06:11] It was really by happenstance. I think, like many people who come out of public accounting or start to look around, I didn’t really know what I wanted to do. I didn’t know what the next move was. So, I reached out to some recruiters, had some less-than-great experiences. I met one in particular that had a similar background to mine, had gone up the ranks in public accounting, gone into recruiting, was successful, opened up an office, and needed her first-time employee.

Joanna Cheng: [00:06:50] So, it was just something I decided try for a year. I mean, I think, from the things I enjoyed the most about being in professional services was the networking aspect, the relationship aspect, the adding value, and, of course, being a profit center versus a call center. So, I thought-

Michael Blake: [00:07:08] Boy, that’s huge.

Joanna Cheng: [00:07:08] Yeah. I thought recruiting could kind of be a good segue into that. And worst thing that could happen is go back and do accounting. So, some years later-

Michael Blake: [00:07:18] Which isn’t so bad.

Joanna Cheng: [00:07:19] Right. Seven years later, it seems to be working out.

Michael Blake: [00:07:23] I guess, it’s worked. Yeah. I mean, you’re still gainfully employed, productive member of society, and we haven’t had to bust you out of jail.

Joanna Cheng: [00:07:29] Yeah, not yet, yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:07:29] So, not yet. So, so far, so good. So, you mentioned you had some experience with recruiters that weren’t so awesome. I think you mentioned that.

Joanna Cheng: [00:07:40] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:07:40] What’s an example of that when you’ve had a bad experience yourself?

Joanna Cheng: [00:07:44] Well, it’s interesting. So, for instance, one of the — part of our process that CFS is we prefer to meet with our candidates in person, just like we like to go on site to our clients, just so we can get a really good 360 feel for the person, and the opportunity, and find that good fit. So, even before I went into recruiting, I mean, I wanted to meet people. I don’t like just virtually knowing people. I feel like I’m best face-to-face. It was just really interesting to me.

Joanna Cheng: [00:08:18] I talked to this recruiter that was referred to me, and it was a great conversation. But, by the end of it, I asked, “Oh, yes. We should meet for coffee. You should probably meet me, make sure I’ve two eyes, and off of my limbs, and yeah.” I mean, he said no, and it was just — I didn’t really know what to think about it because I felt like I couldn’t really adequately work with someone that I had never met in person, especially for such a big decision, which was a possibly career change and change of industry. Experiences like that made me think like, “There’s just got to be a better way.”

Michael Blake: [00:08:56] Yeah. I mean, it’s not like it’s a multi-level marketing scheme. It’s a serious professional position. And in what you do, every time you recommend a hire to a client, I mean, your reputation is big time on the line with that, isn’t it?

Joanna Cheng: [00:09:14] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:09:14] So, how you could go into that, how you could get behind somebody, and put that cloud without meeting the candidate, I’m no recruiter, but I don’t see how I could do that either.

Joanna Cheng: [00:09:24] Yeah, exactly. We’ve done hiring together in our past lives. And, yeah, I think it’s just — We don’t sell paper. And I always say that. And I don’t know if that really resonates. I think that’s a common stereotype among recruiters, and we just throw a bunch of things out there, and we just hope and pray that one of them makes us money. But I mean, there are people behind these pieces of paper. And I’ve seen the best of candidates with the worst resumes. I’ve seen pretty terrible people with really outstanding resumes. That’s part of the sniff test. That’s why we charge for our services. That’s why we have value, and yeah.

Joanna Cheng: [00:10:05] So, along with that, I also worked with a number of recruiters that provided jobs that were clearly not a match for my background. And so, again, I just kept thinking like, “This doesn’t even make sense.” This is not a, “Hey, I need a job. Here’s a job. You want this job?” I mean, it just didn’t make any sense to me. I kept thinking, “Are you even listening to me?” And, of course, I never met these people. So, I mean, I’m like, “Well, you honestly don’t know me from the next person.” So, yeah. So, I think, probably naively, going into recruiting, I thought I can make that just a better experience for people.

Michael Blake: [00:10:47] So, in your opinion, why do you think your clients hire you?

Joanna Cheng: [00:10:54] Really, I wish I knew the answer to that. If there was a concrete answer, I would package it and sell it. Prospecting would be so easy.

Michael Blake: [00:11:02] Well, how about this? How about instead of you, because I know you have a humble streak that we will try to break down and destroy over the course of this podcast. But until we get there, why do people hire you as a profession? Why do they hire somebody like you?

Joanna Cheng: [00:11:20] Well, initially, I think it’s typically out of need. But outside of that, I will say that, just like anything else, whether it’s audit, valuation, services, recruiting, people do business with people they like. I mean, that’s something that’s very important to me is to develop sincere relationships with people and to understand people’s businesses.

Joanna Cheng: [00:11:41] Hopefully, I think, my background is helpful in some sense and really understanding accounting and finance, and what that means to your company for specific positions, but yeah. I mean, it’s either that or my sparkling personality. I mean, I think.

Michael Blake: [00:11:58] I’m sure it’s a healthy combination of the two. But a thought occurred. I’m going to go off the script a little bit but not too far. It’s that, in one respect, what you and I do is very much alike is that I put together merger and acquisition transactions, and you put together talent acquisition transactions.

Michael Blake: [00:12:19] And in what I do, the reason my clients hired me, I think, is because they either have never been through a transaction, or they do it very rarely, right. And the chances are good the other person on the side of that table has done many transactions, okay. And so, they’re hiring me to kind of leverage the expertise of, say, the 200 transactions I’ve done into the one that they’ve done, right.

Michael Blake: [00:12:45] In your world, correct me if I’m wrong, but I think that, hopefully, they’re not hiring all that often for the same position. If they are, that’s a different issue if it’s a merry go round, right. But in an ideal world, you’re maybe hiring once a year, once every couple of years, or maybe once every few months if you’re growing like gangbusters, but that’s still different from somebody whose job it is to hire people 24/7 or place people to be hired 24/7, right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:13:16] Yes.

Michael Blake: [00:13:16] There’s a big advantage to having that expertise and experience in that discussion, isn’t there?

Joanna Cheng: [00:13:24] Well, absolutely. I mean, it’s what we do day in and day out. And I think that’s what the advantage is. I mean, we’re talking to people, we’re talking to companies where we have like the pulse on talent. We can see what’s available, what’s not. And, again, I think, CFS, one thing that we really emphasize is being consultative. I mean, this is, hopefully, not just a transaction. I mean, this is so important to your business. I mean, finding the right controller. And when I say right controller, I mean not someone who understands accounting can do the job. It’s someone who can help your business go from A to Z or wherever it is that you want to go that you like and that likes you.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:02] I mean, that’s the magic, right. That’s what you can’t see from the paper. That’s what you can’t see from an online application. And I think that’s a fallacy that creates the need quite honestly. People have these experiences. We did it ourselves. We found this person. They were perfect on paper. They’re perfect in the interview. They showed up, and they were crazy.

Michael Blake: [00:14:23] Right.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:24] Yeah? And you go, “Well, we hear that story all the time.”

Michael Blake: [00:14:26] Because they don’t say on the resume interests and crazy.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:30] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:14:30] Right? It doesn’t show up, right? And-.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:32] Their representative was like, “Let’s keep that.”

Michael Blake: [00:14:36] It’s on the down low.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:36] Yeah, yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:14:36] Yeah. And, often, the people who have the most polished resumes have them polished because they’re polishing them frequently.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:45] Right, or they’re paying for the polish.

Michael Blake: [00:14:46] They’re paying for the polish, one of the two, right? And you probably developed a spider sense. You must developed a sixth sense of some kind.

Joanna Cheng: [00:14:55] There is a little bit of that. I mean, you do get a feel for people, but that feel is — That’s, I think, the fun part. I think the best part of my job is really knowing my client, understanding their business, and then meeting somebody. I think this happened with you. Meeting someone and going, “Hey, I just met this person, and I just think you should really talk to them. I think they may be a good fit for your group.”

Michael Blake: [00:15:20] That’s true. I’d almost forgotten, I was actually a client of yours.

Joanna Cheng: [00:15:23] Yes. And we know when that works, and those types of situations more than often does, I mean, it’s a good feeling because you just feel like all the stars aligned and maybe you’re good at your job.

Michael Blake: [00:15:40] And that hire worked out. I mean, he stayed longer than I did by a lot. So, I really can’t disagree with that. So, can you point to like a favorite success story of yours where you really helped the company or even maybe helped the candidate out?

Joanna Cheng: [00:15:58] I can think of a lot of stories, but I think one thing, in fact, I had lunch today with a candidate that was a relocation candidate. It’s a really tough and usual position. It was like on the request of one of my favorite clients. And the process was painful, and it was hard because I don’t think either — we didn’t really — we didn’t know what we were looking for until we found it. But I’ve been talking to that candidate today, and how happy they are, and what they’ve been able to achieve in the time they’ve been at the company. I don’t know. It just made — that’s what makes me wake up and do what I do. And, in fact, that client is one of my adventure race buddies.

Michael Blake: [00:16:45] Really?

Joanna Cheng: [00:16:47] So, I’ve recruited for them since their inception as a startup to, now, a very successful business. And that’s something I’m very proud of.

Michael Blake: [00:16:56] So, in addition to running away from alligators and copperhead snakes and jumping over quicksand, you’re doing that.

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:02] Yeah. So, now, we throw ourselves in the briar patches and the like, yes. So, that’s real trust.

Michael Blake: [00:17:08] Yeah.

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:09] That’s when you trust, yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:17:09] Yeah, it is.

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:09] Like your service provider.

Michael Blake: [00:17:13] It is. I don’t know if anybody would trust me to lead them through an alligator or copperhead. In fact, it’s-

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:17] Oh, I didn’t say I led. I’m just, you know, but I’m there.

Michael Blake: [00:17:22] You don’t necessarily shove their head into the water-

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:25] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:17:25] … if something bad happens

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:26] Right. I would put a stick between my client and the alligator.

Michael Blake: [00:17:28] Okay.

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:30] Yeah, yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:17:31] Okay. So, let me ask you. I want to ask you this in a very smart aleck kind of way.

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:37] Okay.

Michael Blake: [00:17:37] Why haven’t you been replaced by websites? They’ve been all over. They’ve come and gone, Monster, Hot Jobs, CareerBuilder, Yahoo Jobs.

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:46] And, again, they all have their place, and they certainly have their success. And we leveraged that technology. We partner, in fact, with some of these companies.

Michael Blake: [00:17:56] Is that right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:17:56] And they’re our vendors. But, again, it just goes back to the relationship. I mean, valuation. I mean, can’t we just make a calculator, and plug in some assumptions, and-

Michael Blake: [00:18:09] There are people that are saying that.

Joanna Cheng: [00:18:10] Yeah. Come up with a number or a multiple and go, “This is the-” It’s not the point. I don’t think that’s how the world works. I mean, we’re not — people aren’t widgets. Talent, it can’t be manufactured. It’s so interesting because, I think, especially within accounting and finance, I mean, people just think, “Oh, I just need a CPA,” or “I just need an AP clerk.” And I don’t know. It’s just like anything else.

Joanna Cheng: [00:18:36] Let’s say, think about you in any job that you’ve ever had, okay. And I don’t know. Maybe people have just been very lucky, and loved everywhere that they worked, and loved the people, and those people love them. But I’ve been in several situations where I could do the job, I did it well, I just didn’t like it, or they like me, and that’s what doesn’t work, right.

Joanna Cheng: [00:18:59] I mean, middle market, in particular, is really attractive to me, (1), because that’s all I know professionally; but (2), it’s like these businesses are often someone’s baby. I mean, they’re trying to achieve a very specific goal. They’re not looking for workers. They’re looking for partners. They’re looking for people who want to be part of this team. They want people to help drive their passion to do whatever it is they want to do with this business. And that just can never be measured by a machine. And I may be eating my own words when Skynet takes over the world. But as for now, I think, my job is safe.

Michael Blake: [00:19:40] Well, I think there’s truth to that. It’s interesting you bring up the valuation part because much of my industry is being replaced by websites. And I don’t think my children would have any interest in doing what I do. But if they did, I don’t think there’s a job there necessarily for them. And we have to move towards an advisory position. And I tell people, if you want a valuation, here’s a website that you can just go get a valuation done. If that’s good enough for you, then do that, right.

Joanna Cheng: [00:20:10] I like that, make valuation.

Michael Blake: [00:20:11] If, on the other hand, you want to learn something about the business that you didn’t already know, that technology is not is not out there yet. And I think I sense that’s a very similar kind of conversation, at least, implicit conversation.

Joanna Cheng: [00:20:27] Yeah, advisory, consultative, it’s all the same thing, right. I think people aren’t looking for an answer. I mean, the answer in valuation isn’t the number. It’s, “Can I achieve my goal? What are your thoughts on that? Do you have any advice for me? What do you think?” And those are the types of questions, and that’s the type of insight, I think, I can provide to my clients. What should the salary reasonably be? Is this reasonable? Historically, this is a person’s background. Does this make sense? Is this a fit?

Joanna Cheng: [00:21:09] And we can talk through all of those things. I mean, again, it’s not a perfect science. I mean, I think that’s one thing that’s always really resonated with me just professionally is an accounting in all things. And I think, I remember you saying this many years ago, but, sometimes, we are looking into a crystal ball, and it’s just not a binary world, and there is no right or wrong. I mean, the perfect — everything could go perfect in the hiring process, and it could be the perfect candidate, but something can happen, and you have to — all recruiting is or financial reporting is just trying to control, and assess, and analyze enough of the variables to, hopefully, ensure success or some type of predictable outcome, but there’s no guarantees.

Michael Blake: [00:22:00] So, let’s talk. The large companies that have their own in-house HR departments, do they also use recruiters, or are they typically bring the whole function in-house?

Joanna Cheng: [00:22:13] Oh no, they absolutely use recruiters.

Michael Blake: [00:22:14] They do, okay.

Joanna Cheng: [00:22:14] Yeah. So, we tend to shy away from large HR departments for that reason. It’s just a lot more cooks in the kitchen than needed. We prefer to work directly with hiring manager and get a better sense of what that position is. Not saying that HR isn’t our ally, and we certainly want to work through their process, but something like a Fortune 100 company is just a completely different beast. And I think if, again, create a financial staffing just specifically, we don’t typically serve that large of a company. We probably aren’t the best resource. We’re not as willing to go and work with a VMS system where, again, in many ways, it’s selling paper. You could be drawing-

Michael Blake: [00:23:03] What is a VMS system?

Joanna Cheng: [00:23:04] Vendor management systems-

Michael Blake: [00:23:06] Okay, yeah.

Joanna Cheng: [00:23:08] … where you have to upload resumes and something, probably a robot, is looking for keywords. Again, anyone can do that. I mean, it just makes no sense to me. I could put CPA controller manufacturing expert on a piece of paper and have that picked up, but is that the right candidate for your job? I mean, maybe, maybe not. But I’ll tell you, like the effort and cost to go through all of that doesn’t really make sense for our model.

Michael Blake: [00:23:38] Now, hiring somebody today is a big commitment. And it’s not just a big commitment economically, but, to some extent, it’s a big commitment legally. And you can’t just hire completely whatever your whim takes you, right. There are certain processes, there’s certain standards of fairness that we have to observe both from a moral standpoint, a legal standpoint. Is that something that you also can help a company navigate to make sure it doesn’t accidentally step in something during the hiring process?

Joanna Cheng: [00:24:10] Absolutely.

Michael Blake: [00:24:11] And you save somebody’s bacon doing that?

Joanna Cheng: [00:24:13] Well, I mean, and I won’t use any specific examples here, but I think especially smaller businesses or owner-operated businesses. People just don’t know what they don’t know. I mean, it’s purely out of ignorance, not out of spite, but yes. I mean, there will be certain things discussed that we’re like, “Yeah, we can’t have that. That can’t be a variable.”.

Michael Blake: [00:24:35] Right. You can’t ask that question.

Joanna Cheng: [00:24:37] Right, or don’t ask that question.

Michael Blake: [00:24:39] Right.

Joanna Cheng: [00:24:42] So, yes. And from a hiring liability perspective, I mean, I think, we do our diligence as well as kind of anyone else, right. You got do your reference checks, background checks. And technology has certainly been very helpful in that that it’s more difficult now, I think, to kind of hide some of your educational or criminal skeletons than maybe you could have in the past.

Michael Blake: [00:25:05] Now, 10 years ago, we saw, remember, the job market was – to use a technical term – in the toilet. But I think firms were even using recruiters then, even in times where there’s ostensibly a much more rich labor pool from which to select talent. Why do you think that is?

Joanna Cheng: [00:25:27] Well, again, your needs are your needs. Very often, that looks and smells a certain way. So, the question to yourself is return and your effort. Your company, your people, your internal efforts, that’s going to cost you money to source and go through kind of just all the bodies, or you could outsource that function to someone that does it every day.

Joanna Cheng: [00:25:55] I mean, again, good economy, bad economy, businesses have to operate. Everyone’s always looking for talent in some respect, whether that’s from a project basis or a direct hire. And I think that each economy has different demands, and that’s why recruiting has kind of been able to navigate these different cycles.

Michael Blake: [00:26:20] So, we hear a lot or I hear a lot, and I’m sure others do, about different models where one fee model is contingency-based, the other is retained search basically. Can you explain kind of the difference between the two? And from a customer’s perspective, what do you think the pros and cons are of each?

Joanna Cheng: [00:26:39] CFS is a contingency model. So, I always like to say I work for free. I get paid upon my success, and I really enjoy that aspect of what I do. Retained search is different the sense that you pay a fee regardless of outcome, in some respects. And those are typically very specialized positions, more difficult to find positions. I mean, national and international searches.

Joanna Cheng: [00:27:08] So, pros and cons. Contingency, I mean, the pro is, again, you can get a lot of recruiters working for you for free. They’re out there kind of kicking bushes, and doing all the legwork, and hopefully bringing in the best of the best, and you can make a hire, and best recruiter wins. The con is those recruiters are working on many different other contingent searches, and you may not be their sole focus, or there could be other drivers of why you’re not seeing what you think you should be seeing from the caliber of candidate, or quantity of candidates, or whatever it is.

Joanna Cheng: [00:27:44] From a retained search perspective, I mean, that typically should be a dedicated effort. I mean, they want not only to take you money, but they do want to earn it. I’m a little bias because I’ve never worked in the retained search model. I think that the only thing I can think of is everyone has to make money, and just makes me wonder sometimes the bandwidth of recruiters even within the retained model like how much time are they truly dedicating to your search. I mean, that’s something to think about. But, again, you got to use who you know and use who you trust, right?

Michael Blake: [00:28:23] Yeah. That’s why you got us. What is a stereotype about your industry or people in your industry that we should dispel? What do most people think about what you do that’s just wrong?

Joanna Cheng: [00:28:35] I’m a big advocate of the saying that stereotypes come from somewhere.

Michael Blake: [00:28:39] Okay.

Joanna Cheng: [00:28:40] Okay. And I think one of the reasons I became a recruiter is because I had terrible experience with recruiters. And I continue to kind of hear those stories often. So, recruiting is a sales job. And I think that’s-

Michael Blake: [00:28:59] Twice over.

Joanna Cheng: [00:29:00] … the reality. That’s the reality of this job. And what I’d like to dispel is that we’re like used car salesmen, and we’re just throwing bodies at companies, and just walking away with a check.

Michael Blake: [00:29:15] Wish, it was that easy, right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:29:16] Oh yeah. I mean, that would be great because that’s the issue is that does happen. And there is a reason why recruiters can have a bad reputation. But what I would encourage people to think about is there are good recruiters, just like there are good accountants, like good doctors, good lawyers, good valuation experts. People who, hopefully, kind of care a little bit more, who take pride in what they do, and really stand behind their business.

Joanna Cheng: [00:29:47] And, also, too, I think, have the luxury to say that as a privately-held company, like we certainly are making things a little bit differently than maybe some of our larger publicly-traded competitors, and they’re driven by a different — they need a different outcome.

Michael Blake: [00:30:02] Well, they’re going to be driven — they have to be driven by a quarterly number, right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:30:07] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:30:07] They have to have 90 days of view ahead of them. And then, after that, they’ll worry about the next 90 days.

Joanna Cheng: [00:30:13] There’s just a reality of that.

Michael Blake: [00:30:15] Yeah, that’s right because that’s what shareholders are telling them they wanted them to do.

Joanna Cheng: [00:30:18] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:30:20] How does a company best work with you? Like you, I’m in the service business, but there are certain conditions in my business where the client does certain things, they make my job a lot easier, and the likelihood of a positive outcome that much greater, right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:30:36] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:30:37] For a company to maximize your effectiveness, what should they be prepared to do on your end as part of that partnership to give the best chance of securing that great outcome?

Joanna Cheng: [00:30:48] Just being available. I think that’s number one.

Michael Blake: [00:30:54] What does that mean exactly?

Joanna Cheng: [00:30:56] I think we’re in this hyper-busy world, especially when you’re a man short, or you need an extra pair of hands. You’re busier than ever. And that drives the backbone of my business. That being said, if you were truly looking for the right fit, you’ll spend the upfront time to invest in speaking with me, so I can learn about your business. You’ll make time for me to come visit, and talk to me in person, and show me around. And when we make our recommendations, really take the time to listen, and discuss, and ask questions.

Joanna Cheng: [00:31:33] I think that’s the best way to work with a recruiter. Like we’re, again, not selling paper. I mean, there are people here. There’s a reason why I’m making a recommendation. If you don’t have the time to talk to me about it, it’s very hard for me to help you. So, I’m often thinking like, “Help me help you.” I know you’re busy, but we’ve got to talk about this, and we’ve got to make time because I think this is a choice.

Michael Blake: [00:31:59] Yeah. I think I would imagine in your world, there are clients that look at you and say, “Oh, thank God, I can just hand this entire thing off to Joanna. She’ll go away for whatever period of time, and she’ll just come back with-”

Joanna Cheng: [00:32:13] A magical unicorn.

Michael Blake: [00:32:14] Magical unicorn.

Joanna Cheng: [00:32:15] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:32:15] Right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:32:16] Mhmm (affirmative).

Michael Blake: [00:32:18] But maybe you’ll come back with a magical unicorn, but if they don’t just sort of throw the thing over the wall, that’s more likely to happen, right?

Joanna Cheng: [00:32:25] Right. Yeah, exactly. And that’s exactly right. I think what happens a lot in recruiting, especially when you’re working, again, with many firms who will just take a general job description and kind of run with it, is, again, these are people, they’re unique. And I do, actually, use that term in my office is we hunt for unicorns. And so, something that like a purple unicorn with a gold horn is very different than the green speckled one. So, when you show up with the pink one with orange sprinkles, and you go, “That’s not what I wanted at all-”

Michael Blake: [00:33:00] It sounds like a very mythical place to work, by the way.

Joanna Cheng: [00:33:01] It’s a magical land.

Michael Blake: [00:33:03] It sounds like it.

Joanna Cheng: [00:33:05] I mean, again, it just comes down to information. And that’s what I typically advise my clients, especially when I first worked with them. I say, “Hey, we present candidates in very small rounds. We like to discuss their backgrounds with you and discuss why we think they would be a fit, and why you should consider them for hire.” And if we’re completely off target, then someone is missing information, or maybe we don’t know what we’re looking for yet. And I see that a lot as well. Sometimes, people think they need these 10 bullet points, and you go, “Well, yes, but this unicorn has six of those, and you don’t even need the other four.” But until you have that conversation and kind of work through that process, you kind of don’t know what you don’t know.

Michael Blake: [00:33:53] And then, maybe, it turns out you don’t need a unicorn, just a really nice horse will do.

Joanna Cheng: [00:33:57] Exactly, yeah, with a party hat on.

Michael Blake: [00:33:59] With the party hat on.

Joanna Cheng: [00:33:59] Yeah.

Michael Blake: [00:33:59] So, last question, and then then we got to wrap up. But I think a lot of people miss the fact that recruiting is an active job. When we call your recruiter, that’s an action-related. To recruit is as active as opposed to just sort of posting a job and waiting for resumes to fill in. And a question I’ve always had and just been kind of curious about is when you recruit somebody who wasn’t necessarily looking for a job at that time, how do you kind of gauge or kind of verify that that person’s really invested in the process, and that if they do kind of make it through your vetting process, you’re going to present them to the client that they’re going, there’s a fully invested candidate, and not just sort of as a hired gun that might be recruited away from them two years later? You know what I mean?

Joanna Cheng: [00:34:55] Well, yeah. And you see that in like the tightest labor market we’ve seen in many years.

Michael Blake: [00:35:00] Right.

Joanna Cheng: [00:35:00] And I mean, I think that in some respects, it’s the new normal, just poaching or the temptation to jump in for what it is when times are good. I think people are always open to opportunity. Again, we can’t see into the future. I don’t know if someone’s going to leave in two years or 20. All we can assess now is your factors causing them to be open to opportunities, like why are they looking? Why would they want your job? Why would they want work here? Why would they stay? I think into overriding all of that is something that is mentioned, but it’s probably not discussed as much as it should, which is retention. Whose job is it to retain these employees? Is it the recruiters’ job?

Michael Blake: [00:35:52] It doesn’t sound like because your job description is not retainer.

Joanna Cheng: [00:35:57] Right. So, that’s something I always think about. And I will say this, I mean, generally speaking, for instance, there are definitely companies that are known for extremely high turnover. And those are companies we tend to shy away from, or we will provide staffing on a project basis. But it’s hard for us to put — I always say it’s hard for us to put A people in kind of a C Company. It’s hard for us to put C people in an A company. It’s the same thing. It doesn’t work.

Joanna Cheng: [00:36:29] So, yeah. I mean, my advice in terms of choosing a recruiter also says, “Hey, yeah, there’s a cost to that. There is a benefit there. There could be some risk associated with it, but what are we doing as a company to retain that talent?” because you can get in the door, but keeping them, that goes beyond my job.

Michael Blake: [00:36:52] Sure.

Joanna Cheng: [00:36:52] And I think that’s pervasive in recruiting. I mean, people switch firms all the time. One thing that attracted me to CFS and kind of holds true in my experiences, our tenure of employees is unusually long for our industry. I do think that says something in a positive way.

Michael Blake: [00:37:14] Well, this went great. We got a lot of great information, great insights, but we can’t cover everything that we’d like to cover in a half-an-hour podcast. So, if somebody wants to ask you some questions, reach out to you, follow up, can they do that?

Joanna Cheng: [00:37:27] Yeah, absolutely.

Michael Blake: [00:37:28] So, how would they reach you?

Joanna Cheng: [00:37:30] I’m on LinkedIn. So, Joanna Cheng with, apparently, not enough of my background. I’ll let you-

Michael Blake: [00:37:41] Yes. Well, it was background-light. We’ll just say you use social media judiciously.

Joanna Cheng: [00:37:47] Right.

Michael Blake: [00:37:47] And Cheng is spelled C-H-E-N-G.

Joanna Cheng: [00:37:48] Yes.

Michael Blake: [00:37:48] Correct?

Joanna Cheng: [00:37:51] And our website is cfstaffing.com. It will have our company number. You’re welcome to give a shout, shoot us an e-mail. Happy see how we can be a resource for you.

Michael Blake: [00:38:03] Okay, very good. Well, that’s going to wrap it up for today’s program. I’d like to thank Joanna Cheng so much for joining us and sharing her expertise with us. We’ll be exploring a new topic each week, so please tune in, so that when you’re faced with your next business decision, you have clear vision when making it. If you enjoy this podcast, please consider leaving a review with your favorite podcast aggregator. It helps people find us, so that we can help them. Once again, this is Mike Blake. Our sponsor is Brady Ware & Company. And this has been the Decision Vision Podcast.

Tagged With: contingency fee, contingency fees, Dayton accounting, Dayton business advisory, Dayton CPA, Dayton CPA firm, Decision Vision, Decision Vision podcast, Decision Vision podcast series, employee recruiting, employee retention, Employee retention strategies, Executive Recruiter, executive recruiting, executive recruitment, financial staffing, hiring a recruiter, hiring candidates, hiring employees, hiring needs, LinkedIn, Michael Blake, Mike Blake, online hiring sites, polished resume, recruiter, Recruiting, resumes, retained search, retaining talent, staffing, talent acquisition, talent recruitment, talent retention, vendor management system, VMS

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2

Business RadioX ® Network


 

Our Most Recent Episode

CONNECT WITH US

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Our Mission

We help local business leaders get the word out about the important work they’re doing to serve their market, their community, and their profession.

We support and celebrate business by sharing positive business stories that traditional media ignores. Some media leans left. Some media leans right. We lean business.

Sponsor a Show

Build Relationships and Grow Your Business. Click here for more details.

Partner With Us

Discover More Here

Terms and Conditions
Privacy Policy

Connect with us

Want to keep up with the latest in pro-business news across the network? Follow us on social media for the latest stories!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Business RadioX® Headquarters
1000 Abernathy Rd. NE
Building 400, Suite L-10
Sandy Springs, GA 30328

© 2025 Business RadioX ® · Rainmaker Platform

BRXStudioCoversLA

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of LA Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversDENVER

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Denver Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversPENSACOLA

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Pensacola Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversBIRMINGHAM

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Birmingham Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversTALLAHASSEE

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Tallahassee Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversRALEIGH

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Raleigh Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversRICHMONDNoWhite

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Richmond Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversNASHVILLENoWhite

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Nashville Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversDETROIT

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Detroit Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversSTLOUIS

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of St. Louis Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversCOLUMBUS-small

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Columbus Business Radio

Coachthecoach-08-08

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Coach the Coach

BRXStudioCoversBAYAREA

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Bay Area Business Radio

BRXStudioCoversCHICAGO

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Chicago Business Radio

Wait! Don’t Miss an Episode of Atlanta Business Radio